Tulsi
Politics • Culture • Lifestyle
Talk story with Tulsi Gabbard
Interested? Want to learn more about the community?
9 hours ago

https://x.com/ArmchairW/status/1938091137723425045

Now that the ceasefire seems to have solidified, my thoughts on the Twelve-Day War between Israel and Iran.

As an initial matter, no armistice that leaves Iran with a direct path to nuclear arms by Christmas can be considered a victory for Israel. And that's where we are.⬇️

Let's run through this.

1. First and foremost, this war was an act of entirely unprovoked aggression by Israel, assisted - at least according to Trump, who may or may not be telling the truth about the matter - by American perfidy in conducting bad-faith negotiations with the Iranians designed only to increase their vulnerability to attack. This isn't even a matter of controversy, the Israelis haven't even tried to claim they had a casus belli and Trump's said on the record that he coordinated with them. This action by the Trump Administration dishonored the United States of America.

2. This was Israel's "big show" against Iran. Its results did not meet the effort expended. The most effective weapon the Israelis had wasn't their vaunted Air Force but instead an elaborately constructed attack network inside Iran courtesy of Mossad - an attack network that is now gone and which likely cannot be reconstructed. To use a hacking analogy, Israel burned all of their "zero-day" exploits in Iran in the last two weeks. Infrastructure can be repaired, weaponry can be replaced, but they're not going to be able to reconstruct this attack network.

3. For all of Israel's talk of taking down Iran's air defense system, the war was almost entirely fought with standoff weapons on both sides. The Israelis flew drones into Iran - and lost a lot of them. They do not appear to have risked their manned aircraft flying "downtown" except in marginal cases. Reports of Israeli aircraft operating with impunity deep in Iran appear to have been misidentification of Iranian Air Force planes at best and propaganda at worst.

4. Both sides' stockpile of standoff munitions appears to have been relatively limited - even with the US likely backstopping Israel with cruise missiles late in the war. This explains the rather limited tempo of strikes on both sides after the first few days far better than claims the Israelis had somehow "suppressed" Iran's missile forces - claims the Israelis "substantiated" with dozens of videos of the same drone strike.

4.a.This also, by the way, explains why Hezbollah seems to have had so many fewer rockets available during Israel's abortive incursion into Lebanon last year than had generally been believed. In an ironic twist and contrary to (consistently wrong about everything!) brOSINT reporting, it seems that it's the Russians with the bottomless doom stockpile of missiles and the Iranians had relatively few on hand.

5. Iran demonstrated a consistent capability to pierce Israeli missile defenses and damage or destroy Israeli infrastructure and combat systems - several IDF air defense missile batteries were in fact struck and destroyed on video in this war. While the reverse is obviously true, given the respective sizes of the combatants Israel would have had to be destroying Iranian critical infrastructure at a rate of approximately ten times what they themselves were suffering just to break even. This did not happen. In fact Iranian "white" civil-use nuclear sites - tertiary targets, militarily speaking - absorbed much of the IAF's wrath.

6. Tying into my point above, there's little indication that even Iranian "nuclear gray sites" such as Fordow or the Natanz bunker were meaningfully damaged in the war. The damage that can be seen on the ground is simply inconsistent with the use of earthquake bombs as claimed by Trump and the Pentagon - although the polite fiction that the sites were destroyed is perhaps helpful to keep the peace. There's little indication the US or Israel even has a clear idea of where Iran's true "nuclear black sites" are actually located, let alone that they effectively struck them during the war.

7. Which leads directly into the point I made upfront. As near as anyone can tell - and if they don't already have them - Iran simply has a straight-line path to nuclear warheads at this point. Their enrichment infrastructure, stockpile of highly enriched uranium, and the black sites at which the work would be done to finish enrichment and manufacture warheads all appear to be intact. And the war that Netanyahu has been threatening for decades to prevent an Iranian nuclear breakout just happened... and succeeded in perhaps disrupting Iran's timetable by a few weeks.

8. The American role in all of this is... well, perhaps "mysterious" is being generous. "Schizophrenic" may be more accurate. Tying the arc of Trump's Truth Social pronunciamentos together with observed actions on the ground gives one the impression that the Trump Administration wrote Netanyahu a blank check in Iran, closely coordinated the road to war with the Israeli government... and then did an about-face when an avalanche of criticism poured in from the American public and it became clear the Iranian state was far from the Syriaesque house of cards that I'm sure Netanyahu painted it as.

9. All of this means that the way forward for Iran is, for once, largely in the hands of the Iranian government. This ties into a broader point of analysis I've touched on several times, which is the Iranian regime's move from being a disruptor-state in permanent revolution towards geopolitical normalcy, industrialization and national growth. BRICS isn't a maniacs' club. To do this they've largely cut loose their constellation of "Axis of Resistance" proxies and reoriented their posture towards conventional defensive deterrence. And, well, it wasn't pretty but I think Israel and the US did in fact get deterred in the end.

10. Very conveniently for anyone in Iran wanting to "normalize" the state and the military going forward, the IRGC took a beating in this war both in terms of raw attrition among its senior leadership and in terms of organizational credibility as a decisive deterrent against Israel. Almost like a lot of people got hung out to dry for blowing Syria and failing to take responsibility, but I digress. The logical way to develop Iranian power and prestige going forward isn't just nuclear warheads but the development of a strong conventional military and intelligence apparatus - something that has sat on the back burner for decades while the IRGC got infiltrated by Mossad and wrote an entire encyclopedia on military gimmicks.

11. This is paradoxically at least somewhat positive for Israeli security going forward. An Iran with a weakened and discredited IRGC, that is integrated into global economic and political systems, is an Iran that will not be seeking confrontation with Israel. It will merely look quite a bit different than Netanyahu's preferred solution of setting everywhere in the Middle East that hasn't been subverted into an Israeli proxy on fire.

So who won? Well, I don't think Iran won - but Israel sure lost.

Interested? Want to learn more about the community?
What else you may like…
Videos
Podcasts
Posts
Articles
The best way to honor our veterans

The best way for us to honor our veterans is to only send our men and women in uniform into harm's way as a last resort, when no other options exist, and actually take care of them and their families if and when they return home. As a Lieutenant Colonel in the Army Reserves, serving as a solider for over 21 years with countless great Americas, this is the actual way to honor our veterans.

00:06:33
Rejecting the neocons’ agenda

This election result is a mandate. It rejects the neocons’ agenda of costly, unnecessary wars and embraces Trump’s promise to end wars, prevent global conflicts, revive our economy, and lower the cost of living for Americans. Entrenched politicians in Washington must take notice, or they may find themselves without a job in the next election.

00:03:31
“Trump-proofing” measures to stymie his presidency

Despite all obstacles, the voice of the American people was heard loud and clear on election night. Now, protecting our freedom requires vigilance. We must be ready to expose and condemn any efforts by the same forces that tried to undermine Trump’s last term as they attempt to do it again—especially through so-called “Trump-proofing” measures designed to limit his ability to govern and fulfill the mandate the American people have given him.

00:02:30
2nd Amendment: Why our right to bear arms "shall not be infringed" — with Rep. Steve Scalise

Tulsi Gabbard tackles the second amendment and her history with gun rights. The former Hawaii Congresswoman and combat veteran explains what experiences caused her to rethink her previously held views. She discusses this and more with House Minority Whip, Louisiana Congressman Steve Scalise, as they recount the harrowing story of his attempted assassination in 2017 and arduous road to recovery. This emotional conversation delves into how that near-death experience reinforced Steve's views on the second amendment and strengthened his relationship with God.

2nd Amendment: Why our right to bear arms "shall not be infringed" — with Rep. Steve Scalise
WARNING: Our civil liberties are under attack - with Ron Paul | The Tulsi Gabbard Show

Tulsi Gabbard connects the dots between American wars and our loss of liberty. The 2020 presidential candidate shows how government weaponizes our own fears against us to pass anti-Constitutional bills like the Espionage Act and Patriot Act. Former Texas Congressman and Libertarian Presidential candidate Ron Paul joins the program to discuss the importance of civil liberties, how they've come under attack and what we must do to preserve them.

WARNING: Our civil liberties are under attack - with Ron Paul | The Tulsi Gabbard Show
Russia, Ukraine and Preventing Nuclear Holocaust with Jeffrey Sachs | The Tulsi Gabbard Show

Tulsi Gabbard reveals the sobering truth about the existential threat of facing a nuclear apocalypse. The former Hawaii Congresswoman who served on the House Armed Services and Foreign Affairs Committees exposes America's role in escalating this new Cold War with Russia. Tulsi is joined by world-renowned economics professor and foreign policy expert, Jeffrey Sachs, to discuss how we arrived at the doorstep of nuclear war and what the Biden administration has done to make matters worse.

Russia, Ukraine and Preventing Nuclear Holocaust with Jeffrey Sachs | The Tulsi Gabbard Show
post photo preview

Hey Huckabee, I heard a report that Israeli settlers are attacking Palestinian Christians. That’s your faith, isn’t it.
.

Here THEY go again!

🚨EMERGENCY ALERT: Same Groups Behind COVID-19 Drills Prepare False Flag Bioterrorism Attack Slated For July 4th To Be Blamed On China / Russia

https://www.banned.video/watch?id=685da1d07a36c57c7a9c331e

post photo preview
Our Final Salute
How to truly honor our fallen on Memorial Day and every day

Memorial Day is always a tough day. While the ads and signs say “Happy Memorial Day!” - for many of us who serve or have served, and Gold Star families, it’s not a happy day. It’s a day to remember our friends who are no longer with us. It’s a day where we think of our last memories with our friends who were killed in combat, thoughts of the loved ones they left behind, and reflection on the selfless sacrifice they made in service to our country.

In 2005, I was deployed to Iraq where I served in a medical unit. Every single day I was confronted with this high human cost of war.

We remember the day that we celebrated their lives, going through the final roll call, and deafening silence when their name was called with no response. We gave them one final salute to their empty boots, helmet, and rifle. 

As we gather at cemeteries and memorials all across the country where our heroes have been laid to rest, we are reminded of the very real, high cost of war, and who pays that price — never forgetting our brothers and sisters who still serve in harm’s way today.

That cost seen in the names on gravestones that we adorn with lei and American flags. The memories of our friends live on our hearts.

So nothing angers me more than to see the hypocrisy every Memorial Day coming from warmongering politicians and media “pundits” who feign respect, gratitude, and empathy for those who paid the ultimate price in service to our country, while simultaneously advocating for more military adventurism, the new Cold War and nuclear arms race.

They don’t seem to understand, appreciate or care about who pays the price for these unnecessary costly wars. They carelessly throw around possible numbers of casualties without recognizing every one of those 'numbers is a person, one of our fellow Americans — someone’s son or daughter, husband or wife, mom or dad.

They don’t know what it’s like to say goodbye to your family and loved ones, giving them one last hug and kiss goodbye, knowing that it could your last.

They don’t know the anxiety that these families live with every single day, every hour and minute, when their loved ones are serving abroad, praying for their safe return and dreading that phone call or knock at the door that could forever turn their world upside-down. 

During my first deployment to Iraq, I didn’t fully understand or appreciate the stress that my family went through. I was focused on my mission and doing my job. It wasn’t until I came home that it truly hit me.  

The plane landed at Hickam Air Force base in the dark pre-dawn hours. We stepped off the plane and walked down the steps to the tarmac, feeling the sweet Hawaii trade wind breezes, as the sky began to turn a beautiful array of pinks and oranges. It was so good to be home. We had our last formation, and the general called out, “Dismissed!" - releasing us after what had been a very long eighteen-month deployment. I ran toward my family, and into the arms of my dad first. As we held each other tight, my dad cried. I had never seen him cry before. It was at that moment that the weight of my service on their hearts became clear.

The way to honor our troops who sacrificed their lives for our country is to prevent unnecessary, costly wars which will result in the deaths of many more of our brothers and sisters in uniform.

While we shed tears, share stories, times of sadness and times of joy, thinking of our friends, celebrating the lives that they lived, let’s remember the purpose they chose for their lives, their strength, courage, and deep love for our country. Let’s make sure that today, and every day, we honor them. We make sure that they are never forgotten and that their sacrifice was not made in vain.

On this Memorial Day, and every day, may we remember those who gave all, and that war should only be waged as the very last resort to keep the American people safe and free.

Read full Article
See More
Available on mobile and TV devices
google store google store app store app store
google store google store app tv store app tv store amazon store amazon store roku store roku store
Powered by Locals